Years ago, I attended a wedding at Willow Creek Community Church outside Chicago. At the time, Willow Creek was one of the largest and most influential churches in the country. The wedding was in a smaller chapel, but a buddy and I sneaked into the main sanctuary. I walked up on the platform, stood behind the pulpit, looked out at all those seats, and said, “I imagined it as bigger.”
I had spent years imagining things as bigger.
I came into ministry in the 1990s, when vision was always supposed to get bigger. We talked about BHAGs—Big Hairy Audacious Goals. Double it. Go up the mountain, get the vision, and bring it back to the people. Outreach Magazine published lists of the 100 largest churches and the 100 fastest-growing churches, as if those were the two measurements that mattered most.
I bought into it. More than that, it appealed to something already in me. I wanted to impress people. I thought I should impress people. I thought I was impressive.
I Thought Bigger Was the Goal
I grew up rural, where people are not easily impressed. In fact, rural people tend to think self-importance is a vice. I didn’t understand the value of that at the time.
When I went to conferences, people would ask me if I lived in a city. I said yes. I lived in a town of 20,000 people, and it was the biggest town for 50 miles. I honestly didn’t understand what they were asking. I lived in the city. It just happened to be surrounded by cornfields.
What they meant was whether I lived somewhere with enough people to support the kind of exponential growth we were talking about. If you wanted to build a church of 5,000, it helped to have 5,000 people nearby.
But I kept importing city-sized ideas into rural settings anyway. At one point I was thinking about multisite church models. Maybe I was ahead of my time. Maybe some of the ideas could have worked eventually. But looking back, I was also setting goals that weren’t built around the resources, talent, and context we actually had.
I was creative, but not always practical. I could imagine the destination much more easily than I could rightsize the next achievable step.
And I wasn’t very good at celebrating when we got somewhere. I thought discontent was a valuable leadership characteristic. If we reached one goal, there was always another one. If the church grew, it should grow more. Even if I had somehow built the largest church, I doubt I would have been satisfied.
For me, size was a black, empty hole.
Maybe the Vision Wasn’t Too Big
For years, I’ve said I don’t have many regrets about that period. I still don’t. I don’t think the lesson is that I should have been less ambitious or stopped believing something significant could happen.
The church I planted never became what 35-year-old me imagined. There were good things that happened there, though. We did meaningful work in the community, particularly in the schools. Today, the church is pastored by someone I mentored, and I love that.
If I could go back, I think I would spend less time trying to make the church bigger and more time developing people and learning how to partner with them. But I also have to give my younger self some grace. I simply didn’t know how to do that yet. It wasn’t all arrogance.
The problem may not have been that my vision was too big. The problem was that I assumed a big vision required a big goal.
I’m beginning to separate those two.
I serve as an interim pastor at a small rural church right now. My last two interim pastorates have been so far from anywhere that if they were farther away, they’d be closer. And I still find myself thinking about attendance growth because, frankly, sometimes I don’t know what else to dream about.
But what if a rural church adopted the second-grade class at the local school? There might only be 25 kids in it. What if the church decided those were their kids to encourage, serve, and support all the way through graduation? Call them the class of 2040.
Twenty-five kids isn’t a big number. Twelve or thirteen years is a very big commitment.
Maybe the vision could be enormous while the next step is appropriately small.
Rightsizing the Next Step
I think this is part of what I’m learning as I enter the final period of my full-time professional life. My vision isn’t necessarily shrinking. At Coach Approach Ministries, our vision is still to express and expand the Kingdom of God through coaching. I don’t know how to make that small.
But I am trying to become much more thoughtful about the next step.
Right now we’re thinking about how coaching can become more deeply embedded in churches and among regional leaders who serve networks of churches. Earlier in my life, I would have been tempted to figure out the grand strategy myself and then find enough people to help me execute it.
The genius with 1,000 helpers.
Instead, I’m involving people who actually work in those contexts and are already having some success. They know things I don’t know. They see things I don’t see. The goal isn’t to get them to help me accomplish my vision. Together, we’re trying to discover what could actually work.
That feels like a significant change.
It also changes what I hope the end of my career looks like. I want a clear vision and a clear strategy. I want successors who value the vision, understand the strategy, and have the competence to carry it. I want people around me to become mature and resilient leaders. I want to write more, mentor more, and continue doing work that matters.
I am still ambitious.
What I’m increasingly willing to let go of is the goal of becoming known as impressive.
I don’t mean I want to become unimpressive. That would just be another way of organizing my life around the same thing. I hope I still write things worth reading. I hope CAM accomplishes things worth noticing. I hope the people around me do remarkable work.
But I’m learning to ask a different question about the next step. Does it fit the people God has actually given us? Does it fit the resources we actually have? Does it make sense in the place where we actually live?
Years ago, I stood behind the pulpit at Willow Creek, looked around at a church that had shaped much of my imagination about ministry, and said, “I imagined it as bigger.”
I’m beginning to wonder whether I’ve spent too much of my life imagining the next thing as bigger.
The vision can stay big.
The next step needs to be the right size.
